The Louisville Institute

The Louisville Institute
1044 Alta Vista Road Louisville, KY 40205 (502) 992-5432


View Past Interviews

Adam Ployd (2013-14 Postdoctoral Fellow) is Assistant Professor of Church History and Historical Theology at Eden Theological Seminary and author of Augustine, the Trinity, and the Church: A Reading of the Anti-Donatist Sermons. LI asked Adam to share his perspective on teaching in the context of Ferguson.

Adam Ployd

On August 9, 2014, Michael Brown, an African-American teenager, was shot and killed by a white police officer in Ferguson, an inner-ring St. Louis (MO) suburb only ten miles north of Eden Theological Seminary where I teach Church History and Historical Theology. Usually, the hardest part of teaching history is making it relevant for students. But that semester, as I guided a group of passionate seminarians through the Reformation and the rise of Modern Christianity, every text seemed to speak immediately to our context, challenging us to responsible, faithful action.

Before the death of Michael Brown, I had already decided to revise my church history course. First, I would focus on the theme of “authority” in all its different manifestations and contestations from Martin Luther to the Enlightenment to Pentecostalism. This would provide a foothold for students trying to keep track of over 500 years of theology. Second, I would begin the class not with Martin Luther but with Martin Luther King, Jr., specifically his “Letter from a Birmingham Jail.” Eden is a progressive UCC seminary, and this text would help students connect right away to material that can otherwise seem esoteric.

When we gathered in September, however, everything had changed. Many students, faculty, and staff at Eden had already been engaged in weeks of protest, advocacy, and ministry in and around Ferguson. Many Eden community members carried signs and shouted for the end of prejudicial policing practices; others felt conflicted, uncomfortable condemning the brave men and women who serve our cities. As one group of students grew tired of talking about race, others arrived late to class, having spent the night tending to wounds from the teargas and rubber bullets that were deployed outside the doors of their churches.

In this context, we gathered to do the work of scholars. We moved from reading MLK’s prophetic response to white moderates in 1960s Alabama to the conflict over religious and political authority between Pope Boniface VIII and King Philip IV of France in the early 1300s. Normally students are chagrined that a Pope would claim wholesale authority over both the church and the civil government. But in the context of the Michael Brown shooting by our own civil authorities and the powerful response by the local clergy community, the conversation about 14th-century church politics suddenly seemed relevant in a difficult and challenging way.

Throughout the semester, I was able to encourage these students and pastors to examine what it means for a church to live and act in a context where its religious authority may necessarily come into conflict with civil authority. How do we draw the line between legitimate advocacy and theological imposition? When should the church work to change the law of the land, and when should the church act as a private community within a larger pluralistic society? I have asked these questions of students before, but never has the discussion been so vibrant or the lived experience of conflict and protest so viscerally present.

Dr. Rick Elgendy (2014-15 Postdoctoral Fellow) is Visiting Assistant Professor of Theology at Wesley Theological Seminary. With Joshua Daniel, Rick is co-editor of a forthcoming volume on political theology: Renegotiating Power, Theology, and Politics. The Rev. Dr. Asa Lee is Associate Dean for Community Life at Wesley Theological Seminary.

Dr. Rick Elgendy

Out of the Classroom and Into the Streets
By Rick Elgendy and Asa Lee

When our everyday discourse contrasts the “ivory tower” with the “real world,” it implies that the classroom is an artifice: a theoretical space of conjecture, set apart from the complexity and exigencies of ordinary life. This reputation is, in many cases, well-deserved. But a seminary – called as it is to address the needs of God’s people in the church and the world – cannot sit on the sidelines of the social struggle for justice. At Wesley Seminary in Washington, D.C., we have seen our community embroiled in the hurt and bearing witness to the healing of the last twelve months.

As a public theologian teaching courses in theology and ethics, Rick Elgendy uses the classroom to encourage reflection on Christian conviction and action. This poses unique opportunities for reflective growth amidst social turmoil: the same week that protests erupted in Baltimore, his Christology course covered Kelly Brown Douglas’s The Black Christ, while his ethics class considered a speech from Jeremiah Wright. A range of understandings of race and “blackness” were offered by students from all backgrounds, many of whom were sorting out their personal involvement and complicity in social structures as they read the news with their developing theological lenses. As we together wrestle with the principalities and powers of our world, the seminary professor can facilitate a deep, honest encounter with challenging thought – even if only by listening, at times.

Dr. Asa Lee

As Wesley Seminary’s Associate Dean of Community Life, Asa Lee works to support students like Rev. Michael Parker II, who is currently the pastor of Ames United Methodist Church in Baltimore. Rev. Parker started at Wesley in the spring of 2011 seeking elder’s orders in the UMC and has always had a strong passion for serving urban communities, particularly his native home. Rev. Parker was childhood friends with Freddie Gray and currently lives on the same block as his family in the Sandtown community.

When peaceful protests began in late April, Rev. Parker was a strong and faithful presence, helping protesters to understand the important social justice witness of the church and creating partnerships to address their righteous anger. As some of the protests turned violent, Rev. Parker became an important voice of reason and calm for much of the activity that was going on right outside his front door. As the violence escalated and the National Guard was deployed, Rev. Parker served as a community pastor that worked to help hurting people in his community deal with the unprecedented violence and responding governmental force. The entire time, this pastor was still trying to complete his studies at Wesley in order to graduate in mid-May.

The unity of our lives means that our experiences will naturally flow into the classroom; the formation we receive – from sources we engage intentionally, like seminary, and unintentionally, like media – will shape our responses to the world around us. But it is still a central task and responsibility of those of us in seminaries to push ourselves toward those difficult questions about who we are and what we will do to transform the world. Time and again, we must remind ourselves that all theology is contextual theology, and our context demands our insightful attention.